Vendor Portal
Author: Mark Ainely | Partner GC Realty & Development & Co-Host Straight Up Chicago Investor Podcast
A Real Look at Chicago's Top-Rated Property Management Companies (Through the Eyes of Another Property Manager)
When you search “Best Chicago property management company” or “Top-rated property managers in Chicago,” you’ll see a handful of names. But if you’re serious about handing your building over to a professional team, don’t just trust the algorithm, look at the numbers.
But this blog isn’t just about us. It’s about understanding how to read reviews like a pro, why some 5-star ratings don’t mean much, and how to spot which companies are really delivering outside of what their reviews say.
REVIEWS 101: WHY STAR RATING ISN’T EVERYTHING
A company with 5 stars and 3 reviews? That might be three friends or three lucky customers.
A company with 4.6 stars and 700+ reviews? Now you’re looking at a consistent reputation across hundreds of touchpoints.
Here’s why volume matters just as much as rating:
Consistency – A high number of reviews shows that they’ve delivered steady service, not just a few lucky breaks.
Time-tested – The more reviews, the more years likely behind them. You can’t fake 500+ happy customers.
Resilience – Even the best companies have the occasional hiccup. A strong rating despite the tough reviews shows how they respond to issues, and that’s important.
And remember this: bad actors can spam a page with glowing reviews overnight. But you can’t fake trust over years, we all know that.
The best Chicago property management companies aren’t just visible, they’re verifiable.
TOP-RATED CHICAGO PROPERTY MANAGERS (AS OF 2025)
Here’s a snapshot from Google reviews:
GC Realty & Development – ⭐ 4.6 | 762 reviews
Landmark Property Management – ⭐ 4.8 | 243 reviews
Chicago Property Services, Inc. – ⭐ 4.5 | 69 reviews
HomeRiver Group Chicago – ⭐ 4.2 | 229 reviews
Hales Property Management – ⭐ 4.6 | 498 reviews
PRG Management – ⭐ 4.6 | 🗳️ 146 reviews
Now let’s interpret:
Landmark Property Management (4.8 stars / 243 reviews)
Strong rating, mid-tier volume. A solid name in Chicago, and we’ve had a number of conversations with landlords who’ve spoken well of their services.
Chicago Property Services (4.5 stars / 69 reviews)
While they have fewer reviews than some other firms, their longevity and track record in the city suggest a loyal client base and experience in navigating the unique challenges of Chicago buildings.
HomeRiver Group Chicago (4.2 stars / 229 reviews)
Part of a national brand. Lower rating suggests some challenges with scale, but every management company has its strengths depending on the property type.
Hales Property Management (4.6 stars / 498 reviews)
Established firm with great infrastructure. We’ve run into them many times in this market and appreciate their professionalism.
PRG Management (4.6 stars / 146 reviews)
Another strong player in the mix. We’ve heard solid things from owners and agents alike.
GC Realty & Development (4.6 stars / 762 reviews)
What sets us apart?
Highest review volume on the list
20+ years of building landlord trust
Deep integration with the investor community
Proactive content that educates the market — not just sells services
And most importantly — we’re trusted by hundreds of landlords year after year because we own investment property ourselves. We know what it’s like to be in your shoes. And we know what it takes to be successful!
READING BETWEEN THE STARS: THE REAL STORY IN NEGATIVE REVIEWS
No one’s perfect. The question is: what happens when things go wrong?
When you scroll through Google reviews, keep an eye out for how companies handle criticism:
Do they respond with professionalism?
Do they offer a solution or go silent?
Are issues one-off or part of a trend?
Are they accountable for the mistakes they made?
Here’s what we tell every landlord: a review isn’t just a score, it’s a case study. Some of our best owners today found us because they saw how we responded to tough feedback. That kind of transparency builds trust.
THE REAL JOB OF A PROPERTY MANAGER? TRUST AND TIME MANAGEMENT
Being a top property manager in Chicago means more than collecting rent. It means being the front line for:
Legal compliance with evolving ordinances
Emergency calls and building issues
Screening and placing high-quality tenants
Protecting long-term asset value
You want someone who can take all of that off your plate while giving you full visibility into performance. That’s where great property managers earn their keep.
IF YOU’RE A LANDLORD: HERE’S WHAT TO DO NEXT
✅ Compare Google reviews — but prioritize volume AND content
✅ Read the company’s blogs and videos — do they educate you or just advertise?
✅ Ask how many buildings they manage like yours and ask confidently
✅ Look for response time and tenant satisfaction in the feedback
✅ Pick the team that understands your goals — not just the lease terms
And when you’re ready, come see why GC Realty & Development has become the first call for so many Chicago property owners.
We’re proud to stand next to the other top-rated companies in this market — and we’re proud to keep raising the bar.
There is a lot of information contained here if you plan on investing in real estate locally. It may seem overwhelming for those wanting to invest in the Chicago market, but it is really just a team sport. Who is on your investing team? Do you even have a team? GC Realty & Development, LLC. has a dedicated team of professionals that are willing to share their decades of experience in all facets of real estate. We handle everything from Brokerage, Leasing and Property Management. Whether you hire us or not, we are happy to provide you with our resources and expertise.
What gets me up in the morning and keeps me going twelve hours a day is the ability to add value to local area investors, in Chicago and beyond! Those who connect with me often hear me say that our goal is to bring value to everyone we come in contact with. We hope that in return, they will one day hire us for our Tenant Placement,or Property Management Services, refer us to someone they know, or leave us a review about our services. We would clearly love all three, however, we are happy whenever we get the opportunity to help!
Reach out today!
Partner / Co Host of Straight Up Chicago Investor Podcast
